Updated November 2026
Finding gag gifts for Secret Santa is easier when you know what makes a joke gift land well. This list covers five novelty picks chosen for broad humor, low risk of offense, and a size and price feel that suits a typical office or friend-group swap. Each pick was assessed by checking listing details, brand reputation and common owner feedback patterns rather than hands-on use.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallFunwares Porta Potty Shot GlassesView on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for a holiday themeFreeNFond Reindeer MankiniView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for office desksDecodyne Funny Coffee MugView on Amazon - 4
Best for a stocking-stuffer prankGelid Gift Not Included Batteries Gag GiftView on Amazon - 5
Best for a mixed-gender groupFandicto Fake Beer Belly Waist PackView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Funwares Porta Potty Shot Glasses | Adult gift exchanges | Set of two shot glasses |
| FreeNFond Reindeer Mankini | Holiday party laughs | Bells and reindeer design |
| Decodyne Middle Finger Mug | Office gift swaps | 14-ounce ceramic mug |
| Gelid Gift Not Included Batteries Gag Gift | Stocking-stuffer pranks | Classic “batteries not included” joke |
| Fandicto Fake Beer Belly Waist Pack | Mixed-gender groups | Adjustable belly-shaped pouch |
Funwares Porta Potty Shot Glasses
Toilet-Shaped Humor, Durable Scratch-Resistant Plastic, White Elephant, Secret Santa & Shot Glass Collector Favorite Funwares Porta Potty Shot Glasses, Set of 2, 2 oz Novelty Gag Gift for Men
Best for: Adult gift exchanges with a bit of crude humor.
These toilet-shaped shot glasses suit groups who already enjoy party gags. The set of two makes them easy to pair with a bottle or to give as a couple’s gift.
Pros
- Set of two, so they work for two recipients or a shared joke.
- Scratch-resistant plastic that owners often describe as sturdy.
Cons
- Plastic feel will not suit anyone wanting a premium drinkware look.
FreeNFond Reindeer Mankini
FreeNFond Christmas Gag Gift Reindeer Mankini Men Thong Underwear with Bells for White Elephant Exchange Gifts Valentine's
Best for: Holiday parties where the group is comfortable with bold costume humor.
This novelty garment with festive bells is aimed at people who want a loud, seasonal joke. It works best when everyone in the exchange is clearly in on the fun.
Pros
- Strong seasonal theme that fits Christmas parties directly.
- Bells add an audible, comedic element during gift opening.
Cons
- Too revealing for many workplaces, so check the group first.
Decodyne Funny Coffee Mug
Decodyne Funny Coffee Mug, Gag White Elephant Gifts for Adults and Coworkers – Perfect for Christmas, and Novelty Gifts, Middle Finger Mug, 14 Ounce (Black)
Best for: Office swaps where a mild, everyday joke is the goal.
A coffee mug is a practical item people use daily, so the joke stays with the recipient long after the exchange. It suits coworkers who share a sense of dry humor.
Pros
- Practical 14-ounce size that people actually use.
- Gag design reads clearly from across a desk.
Cons
- The middle-finger design may be too rude for some offices.
Gelid Gift Not Included Batteries Gag Gift
Gelid Gift Not Included Batteries Gag Gift – Funny Prank for Present Adults for Women Men – Stocking Stuffer for Him Her Boyfriend Girlfriend
Best for: Light pranks and small stocking-stuffer style exchanges.
This gift is built around a single classic joke, so it works well when the budget is modest and the group wants a quick laugh. Pair it with a small real item for a fuller present.
Pros
- Works for a wide range of recipients, including couples.
- Easy to wrap and fits well inside a stocking.
Cons
- The joke is simple, so it may feel thin as a main gift.
Fandicto Fake Beer Belly Waist Pack
Gag gifts Christmas Gift Exchange,Fake Beer Belly Waist Pack,Dadbod Dad Bag,PU Leather,Large Capacity,Adjustable Waist Fandicto White Elephant Gifts Funny Belly Bag Fanny Pack for Men Women
Best for: Mixed-gender groups that want a funny item with real use.
This adjustable belly-shaped pouch is a fun dad-bod joke that doubles as a working bag. It fits well when you want something both silly and functional.
Pros
- Large capacity with an adjustable waist strap.
- Usable as an everyday fanny pack, so it is not wasted.
Cons
- The joke is tied to a body-image gag, which some people may find awkward.
Buying Guide
Know your group’s comfort level
Office swaps call for milder jokes than close friend groups. If you are unsure, pick something that would be fine with a manager watching.
Match the joke to the theme
Holiday-themed gags feel more connected to the season. Generic novelty items work at any party but can feel less festive.
Check the budget feel, not just the number
A small, well-chosen gag often beats an expensive joke that falls flat. Aim for something that looks thought through.
Consider pairing with a small extra
A single gag gift can feel thin on its own. Adding a candy bar or small treat makes the exchange feel more generous.
Good picks for this: Funwares Porta Potty Shot Glasses, Decodyne Funny Coffee Mug
FAQ
What counts as a good gag gift for Secret Santa?
A good gag gift gets a laugh without embarrassing anyone. It should be easy to understand at a glance and suit the group’s sense of humor.

